Discovering Arnis Monticello: A Local Culinary Gem
Nestled in the heart of Monticello, Indiana, Arnis Monticello stands as a cherished local establishment, offering a welcoming atmosphere and a commitment to quality dining experiences. Located conveniently at 517 N Main St, Monticello, IN 47960, United States, this restaurant has cultivated a reputation built on consistency, genuine hospitality, and a menu that thoughtfully balances familiar favorites with intriguing culinary touches. It is more than just a place to eat; it is a community hub where neighbors gather, families celebrate milestones, and visitors find a true taste of local flavor.
The essence of Arnis Monticello lies in its dedication to providing an environment where every guest feels valued. From the moment you step through the doors, the ambiance suggests a place that respects tradition while embracing the needs of the modern diner. Whether you are seeking a quick, satisfying lunch or a relaxed evening meal, the setting is designed to accommodate and enhance your experience. The careful attention paid to service ensures that your visit is seamless, allowing you to focus entirely on the company and the food.
Understanding the local dining landscape requires recognizing those establishments that consistently deliver on their promises. Arnis Monticello has achieved this through unwavering focus on core principles that resonate deeply with patrons. They have successfully carved out a niche that appeals to a broad audience, demonstrating versatility in their offerings without sacrificing the integrity of their culinary approach. This dedication to excellence, right here on Main Street, makes it a noteworthy destination for anyone passing through or residing in the area.
Key Highlights of the Arnis Monticello Experience
To truly appreciate what Arnis Monticello brings to the table, several key aspects define its appeal and distinguish it within the local dining scene. These elements combine to create a memorable and repeatable experience for patrons:
Commitment to Freshness and Quality Ingredients: At the core of Arnis Monticello’s philosophy is a strong emphasis on sourcing and preparation. The kitchen prioritizes using high-quality components in every dish, ensuring that the final product reflects care and attention from the initial selection to the final plating. This dedication to ingredient quality is palpable in the taste and texture of their offerings.
Warm and Inviting Atmosphere: The restaurant successfully cultivates an environment that feels both refined and deeply comfortable. It strikes that perfect balance, making it suitable for casual drop-ins yet elegant enough for special occasions. The interior design and the demeanor of the staff contribute significantly to this welcoming aura.
Versatile Menu Selection: Patrons often praise the breadth and depth of the menu. It is thoughtfully curated to offer something appealing to diverse palates, ensuring that whether a diner prefers classic comfort food or something slightly more adventurous, there is a satisfying choice available. This versatility makes repeat visits exciting.
Central and Accessible Location: Situated prominently at 517 N Main St, Arnis Monticello benefits from its accessible location within Monticello. This prime spot makes it an easy destination for local residents and a convenient stop for travelers exploring the region, solidifying its role as a key local landmark.
A Culinary Anchor in Monticello
Arnis Monticello represents the best of what a dedicated, community-focused restaurant can achieve. It is a place where the quality of the food is matched only by the warmth of the service. The establishment understands that dining out is an experience that involves all the senses, from the initial visual appeal of the plate to the lingering satisfaction after the last bite.
For those seeking an authentic taste of Monticello hospitality, Arnis Monticello offers a reliable and delightful option. The team works diligently behind the scenes to maintain high standards across all aspects of the operation. This consistent performance is what transforms a simple meal into a cherished memory and encourages patrons to return time and again.
We invite you to experience the dedication and flavor that define Arnis Monticello. Discover why this location on North Main Street has become a beloved fixture for so many in the community. Arnis Monticello is ready to welcome you for your next memorable dining occasion.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Serves local specialty
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Coffee
Quick bite
Vegetarian options
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Amenities
Toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Quiet
Crowd
Family friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Locals
Tourists
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Menus
Photos
Reviews Arnis Monticello
Kathleen Preston
24-06-2026
Love this Arni’s- we always have great service!! The Arni’s Senior Junior salad is my fav and the hubby is all about the pizza. If you’re looking for someplace good- check it out!!
Dan Lah
14-06-2026
First time at this Arni’s. Food is great like all the others but honestly, the atmosphere is not good. Only Arni’s I’ve ever been to where you order at counter and then sit down and wait for your food. I had a party of six and everybody’s … More
shane spencer
09-06-2026
Went in to check out wait times on a holiday weekend after a similar establishment was on a 2 hour wait. They stated 35-45 mins at 32mins they were completed and apologized for the delay. I stated there was no apology needed they were right on time and I had time to observe the stay all working together as a great team! More
jcj sutt
21-05-2026
Food is usually good but the fried chicken on my salad was horrible. It was very dry and hard. Didn’t notice until I got it home. Oh well dog got a crunchy snack. More
Robert Caplinger
05-05-2026
Pizza was excellent and Sandwich Tex BBQ hit the spot, had t been in Monticello in yrs eating there.
Linda Douthitt
28-04-2026
I ordered two 10 in. Pizzas and bread sticks with nacho cheese. Pepperoni pizza wasn't good at all and they gave me cheddar cheese instead of nacho and the bread sticks were hardly even cooked. I can't vouch for the other pizza I didn't eat it. I will not return to Monticello location again only to the main branch at Market Square. More
Donald Doyle
25-04-2026
This places pizza is a joke! It is worse than the school lunch pizza I had 50 years ago! … More
Kathy Maker
12-04-2026
The "person" we had bringing our food and drinks was horrible!!!! Had to keep reminding her of things we needed, the food came out at different times, the worst I have ever had!!! Definitely won't be going back there!!!!!!! More
J Anthony
06-04-2026
We love this place, the prices are very competitive and reasonable. Employees are very friendly and helpful. More
Catherine Joan Seager
27-03-2026
Met you at Arni's! They've remodeled. Same great people working, plenty of seating (indoor & out), food is amazing! More
Kerri Poniatowski
25-03-2026
Friendly staff. You order up front and sit in the back to eat. Quick and tasty.
Meal type…
More
Russel Hoffman
20-03-2026
My Dad, his wife, my wifey and I ate there last week. I haven't been there in 15 years or so. Nice to know its still FANTASTIC! Good service, GREAT pizza, I opted out on the salad this time, I shouldn't have, maybe next time. It was my wifeys first time, she agrees. We WILL be back! Thankyou again, keep up the great work and sevice. - Royal Center
Food: 5
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 5
Natasha Ingle
19-03-2026
We got 2 large pizzas. One had pepperoni, ham & mushrooms. The other was a BBQ chicken pizza. They were so gross especially the BBQ chicken pizza. I've had arnis a couple different times and it was good but this time was definitely not. It was like they used ingredients that did not belong on pizzas. It was so bad idk how to even explain it. I wish I had remembered to take pics but I didnt regrettably.
Service
Take out
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 1
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 3
Wait time
No wait
Seating type
Indoor dining area, Booth seating
Recommendation for vegetarians
Somewhat recommend
Vegetarian offerings
Not sure
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Kid-friendliness
It is kid friendly dining.
cathie blameuser
15-03-2026
Haven't ate at an Arni's since way back when they were on the Levee in Lafayette. The quality has went way 👇, nothing at all how it used to be. I was pretty disappointed 😥 and won't return. The staff was nice and the service was quick. … More
Claire Grant
02-03-2026
We always have a pleasant experience with Arnie's! So glad we have this food option in our town. We are never disappointed with our meals, and love the new remodel in Monticello In,very nice update. More
Jaden Roth
23-02-2026
Rylie and taylor were very respectful as workers towards me and the pizza as well as the ranch dressing were wonderful! Highly recommend. The renovations that were done to the restaurant look great as well!
Service
Take out
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Group size
Suitable for all group sizes
Wait time
No wait
Brandon Rhine
11-02-2026
The best pizza and salads around. Aidens big show pizza is great. A new favorite.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$1–10
Michael R Huppenthal
29-01-2026
Nice and clean.. food is great.. service was really good too.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Lori Geldes
01-01-2026
I had the Cheese Steak sandwich. It was delicious!
Service
Take out…
More
Kerri Poniatowski
29-12-2025
Friendly staff. You order up front and sit in the back to eat. Quick and tasty.
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Very quiet
Wait time
No wait
Kevin Foster
20-12-2025
Reserved a table for 12. When we got there someone was sitting at it who had 11 friends coming. Ok. Honest mistake. No wait staff to take your order. Works like an uppity fast food joint. Order at the counter then they'll bring it to you. … More
Lexi Leach (Lex)
13-12-2025
The place is nice looks good but the pizza is flat and me personally like my pizza puffy, they also add to much toppings that fall off when eating, very messy. More
Jolene Maxine Boller (Boob)
13-12-2025
It is delicious and always has been. Clean as well organized. Food was done in no time. Great puzza
Service
Dine in
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 4
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 3
Wait time
No wait
Seating type
Private dining room
Donald Doyle
29-11-2025
This places pizza is a joke! It is worse than the school lunch pizza I had 50 years ago!
DON’T WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY. Go to Pizza Hut - trust me.
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 1
Service: 1
Atmosphere: 1
Wait time
No wait
Nicholas Wertz
13-11-2025
I ABSOLUTELY love Arnis. Best pizza in town, family owned, great staff, always accommodating. Super excited for when the construction upgrades are finished. 10 of 10 is an understatement, ARNIS IS THE BEST
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$1–10
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Mozzarella Sticks, 7 Cheese Pizza and 14 Pepperoni Pizza
Nicholas Gustafson
10-11-2025
One of a kind pizza joint that you have to check out if in the area! The staff are all super friendly. Pizza came out hot and fresh, tasted great. PS don't forget to add the cheese on your salad 🥗. If you know, you know. … More
Brandon Rhine
28-10-2025
The best pizza and salads around. Aidens big show pizza is great. A new favorite.
Service…
More
Joshua Cox
11-10-2025
Pizza and cheesesticks were very good. The food arrived fast. The typical teenage wait staff. Was messy in the dining area. Will take to go next time.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Food: 5
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 1
Group size
3-4 people
Patrick Wright
03-10-2025
This place is just ridiculous!! It could be a great place but our second time here was worse than the first. The amount of untrained ignorant soft speaking kids behind the counter is nuts. We have never eaten in and didn’t know how the … More
Monte “Marty” Adams
03-10-2025
good food and good prices good service..good dining experience..
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Wait time
No wait
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Laurie Anne Delaney
26-09-2025
Such good food and excellent service for us out of towners❣️ Thank you for your time today❣️
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Karl Papka
19-09-2025
The young men working here killed it, the food was made obviously with thoughtfulness and love...it was so good
We had 2 pizzas and 2 sandwiches, service was super fast. Delicious More
Chaston Baird
15-09-2025
Was a little weird, order in the front and seat yourself in the back, but they did bring it out and take a party of 15 in an instant. Food was good, music was quiet but classic dad rock, baseball on the tv. Bathrooms were accomadating.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Food: 5
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 3
Wait time
No wait
Recommendation for vegetarians
Not sure
Vegetarian offerings
Not sure
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
Richard Rinehart
09-09-2025
I Love their pizzas. They ground up all the meats, that's how we like it. And their salads are plentiful, enough to share. Nice place to chow down! More
Sarah Sheridan
04-09-2025
I grew up eating this pizza and their Jr. salads! We live in Ohio and only get to visit every now and again, but the pizza and salads are always the same, delicious! Consistency is more than nostalgia, especially for 40+ years! More
Ashley Bumbalough
03-09-2025
It had been years since I was somewhere close to an Arni's I missed it and oh it was amazing!
Food:…
More
Scott Akers
29-08-2025
Service wasn't the greats ..they for got my pizza and waited over 30 mins after I order for them to make it .. More
carol green
24-08-2025
This was my favorite place growing up and was bragging how great their pizza was so we had to get one. However, it was so burnt we could barely eat it. It was very sad to see how much it had changed. More
Brenda Steffan
18-08-2025
First time ever trying Arni's. Ordered large sausage and cheese pizza to go. Not enough cheese, No sauce, no taste, over cooked..In the top 5 pizzas ever ordered. Won't be back. $15.83 More
Donald Mccall
12-08-2025
Was expecting a Stromboli sandwich, was a take out order. Very disappointed non tradition Stromboli, ground sausage onions little pizza sauce little to no cheese, very bland. Your not getting a Stromboli sandwich but a cheap pizza sandwich.
Service
Take out
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 1
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 4
Group size
1 person
Recommendation for vegetarians
Would not recommend
Lori Geldes
17-06-2025
I had the Cheese Steak sandwich. It was delicious!
Service
Take out
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Seating type
Indoor dining area
Tom Bombadil
15-06-2025
Ground Pepperoni pizza and an Arni's Jr. Salad will be worth the detour, can't wait for another road trip to stop. Pizza is still great after heating it back up in the oven. More
Ron Branch II
12-06-2025
I ordered a hot Sicilian sub with tater tots and my wife had a hot ham and cheese sub with fries. Both meals were ok, but not exceptional. The pizza looked good, but we did not try that.
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 3
Service: 3
Atmosphere: 3
Noise level
Very quiet
Wait time
No wait
Monte “Marty” Adams
07-06-2025
good food and good prices good service..good dining experience..
Service…
More
Michael R Huppenthal
25-05-2025
Nice and clean.. food is great.. service was really good too.
Food: 5…
More
Marlaina Payne
05-05-2025
So right off the bat, I was second guessing this restaurant because the outside of the building is falling apart. Rotten wood everywhere. The building looks deserted, the parking lot has no lines, we weren't really sure where to park. … More
Reviews Arnis Monticello